Log in

No account? Create an account
Spacecrab's Journal
LB in SF
Brief movie commentary: A Scanner Darkly 
7th-Jul-2006 11:36 pm
This one is a real PKD movie. I have some nitpicky quibbles with the direction of the actors, especially in the first fifteen minutes. But, eventually, either they all fall into their characters or my brain gets tired of going "Cut! This scene needs more *punctuation*."

It's only an excerpted montage of the book, but 99% of it is Phil Dick's words -- and they chose all the right scenes. Arctor, Luckman, and Barris discovering Donna's roach in the ashtray is perfectly executed. Keanu Reeves really looks too young for Bob Arctor. But Woody Harrelson nails the Barris character.
[[7-9-06: Barris is nailed by Robert Downey, Jr. Harrelson plays Ernie Luckman ]]

Winona Ryder was also very good, even though she says she had no idea what the movie was all about. (See here.)

Richard Linklater (the director) inserted one plot twist toward the end of the movie that I never picked up in the novel. I'm going to have to go back and reread it to see if that was really in there.

By the way, the speaker notes for the Potlatch 14 "A Scanner Darkly" panel, featuring Bruce Gillespie and Grania Davis, are still around at the Potlatch website. Can't pimp this too often, after all the time I spent transcribing and posting the stuff.
8th-Jul-2006 03:02 pm (UTC)
Most of my friends have been going to see "Superman" and then whining about how lousy it was. What did they expect?

And this weekend, "Pirates of the Caribbean." Sheesh.

You, on the other hand, are seeing a film I want to see, and when either I get up there or it comes down here, I shall certainly do so.
This page was loaded Apr 21st 2019, 9:16 pm GMT.